If you’ve ever tried to figure out which magic mushroom (available with Offerings) is “best,” you already know it gets confusing fast. There are species, strains, sub-strains, nicknames, and potency charts that feel like they belong in a lab instead of a conversation. I remember the first time I looked into this — I thought there were maybe three types. Turns out there are over 200 psilocybin-producing species, and they don’t all feel the same.
The good news is you don’t need to be a scientist to understand the basics. Most people want to know which mushrooms are stronger, which ones feel smoother, and which are a good starting point. Researchers have actually looked at this, measuring the psilocybin and psilocin levels in different species and strains, and the results help paint a simple picture.
Let’s break it down so you can understand your options without feeling lost.
The Most Common Starting Point: Psilocybe cubensis
If you’ve heard of magic mushrooms, you’ve almost definitely heard of P. cubensis. It’s the classic one that people talk about, and the strain with the most variation. Scientists studying cubensis strains point out something pretty important:
“Different P. cubensis strains showed notable differences in psilocybin and psilocin levels even under similar cultivation conditions.”
That means two mushrooms that look similar could still hit differently. Popular strains like Golden Teacher, B+, and PES Amazonian all fall under this species, but their effects can feel unique. Most beginners start with cubensis because it’s moderate in potency, predictable, and widely studied.
Stronger Options: Psilocybe azurescens and Friends
If you’ve ever heard someone say a tiny mushroom sent them to the moon, they were probably talking about Psilocybe azurescens. Lab analysis shows that it’s one of the strongest species out there, sometimes several times stronger than average cubensis.
Researchers analyzing multiple species noted:
“Potency varied greatly between species, with P. azurescens consistently exhibiting the highest concentrations of tryptamine alkaloids.”
This species isn’t for beginners. It’s powerful, mentally intense, and usually better suited for experienced users who know how to navigate deep experiences.
The Middle Ground: Psilocybe semilanceata
Also known as “Liberty Caps,” these mushrooms are tiny but surprisingly potent. They’ve been studied across large batches, and their alkaloid levels are often higher than cubensis but lower than azurescens.
People describe the effects as clean, energetic, and emotional. They don’t grow easily in controlled settings, which means most people don’t start with them, but they show up in scientific potency charts a lot.
Choosing Based on What You Want
Most people base their choice on the type of experience they’re looking for. Here’s a simple way to think about it:
If you want something gentle and steady → Cubensis (Golden Teacher, B+, etc.)
If you want something stronger with deep introspective potential → Semilanceata
If you want something very strong and intense → Azurescens
If you want variation within one species → different cubensis strains offer different profiles, even if their potency is moderate overall.
One LC-MS/MS study analyzing strain differences made this clear:
“Potency differences among P. cubensis strains were significant, supporting the idea that strain selection may influence the intensity of effects.”
So even within the same species, your experience can shift.
What About Microdosing?
If your goal is microdosing, cubensis is almost always the go-to option. The potency is consistent enough that you can measure tiny amounts more reliably. Highly potent species like azurescens can make microdosing tricky because the difference between a microdose and too much becomes razor thin.
I’ve heard people say that Golden Teacher gives them a calmer, more predictable microdose, while other strains feel slightly more stimulating. That lines up with what some growers and researchers see in alkaloid breakdowns.
Things to Consider Before Choosing
A mushroom isn’t just a mushroom. Its effects depend on:
- where it was grown
- how it was dried
- how strong the strain naturally is
Two mushrooms from different batches of the same strain can feel slightly different. That’s why many people pick a species or strain that has plenty of information and user experience behind it.
Summary
Choosing the right magic mushroom depends on what kind of experience you want. P. cubensis is the most common and beginner-friendly, with lots of strains to explore. P. semilanceata sits in the middle with a clean and strong effect. P. azurescens is extremely potent and better for experienced users. Studies show that both species and strains vary widely in their psilocybin and psilocin levels, so picking the right one matters. And if microdosing is your goal, cubensis strains usually offer the most consistency.
Sources
MDPI – Exploring Psilocybe cubensis Strains: Cultivation Techniques, Psychoactive Compounds, Genetics and Research Gaps
MDPI – Extensive Collection of Psychotropic Mushrooms with Determination of Their Tryptamine Alkaloids
ScienceDirect – Determination of psilocybin and psilocin content in multiple Psilocybe cubensis mushroom strains using LC–MS/MS
Read Our Other Articles